Soubs Salute/ The Back of Beck? / Guest Post by Rish Baruah.

Loads of stuff to cram into a post tomorrow, dealing with what looks like a new future for the media in Nottingham: you’ll have to wait for that though.  I also have a bit of news about when I met the Shadow Minister for Small Business (and our erstwhile MP, Dr Palmer)  last week, and got into a bit of an argument. However, a few quick things to run through before I hand over to a guest contributor, Rish Baruah.


So I’ll confuse usual readers instantly by giving Soubry a round of applause. Yep. Credit where it’s due, she’s pledged to vote in favour of same-sex marriages this week: it’s rumoured that some marginal Tories will vote against, or simply abstain, but Anna has been pleasingly bullish and pledged to vote. So well done, Anna. There, I said it.


News reaches me that, hot on the heels of the closure of Hoggs butcher, Beck’s Bargains is to shut very soon. I best state this is not as yet verified as I only heard after it had closed for the day, but it seems the staff were given no notice, but successfully protested their rights and were as such granted a stay of execution. I’m sad it’s going: where else can you pick up five – yes FIVE- Crunchies for a quid?? It’s about as far from Waitrose as it’s possible to get, but that is not a complaint. Friendly staff, super cheap food, recycled plastic bags. Boo to the owner, i say. What a loser…

<iframe width=”420″ height=”315″ src=”; frameborder=”0″ allowfullscreen>


Right, over to Rish, (who is more famous for being the brains behind Forest blog,  and the former assistant editor of The Beestonian. Usual disclaimer, the views of hosted pieces do not necessarily reflect my own views, etc.

Be careful what you wish for 


If ever a constituency was a microcosm of the country as a whole, it is surely Broxtowe. A wafer-thin majority, whereby the Tory candidate won the balance of power by the Lib Dems splitting the opposition vote; a diverse constituency featuring some affluent areas, and some areas which are downright struggling; a demographic featuring young single mothers, council tenants, private renters, middle-class families, and a number of elderly residents.

Despite having roots a couple of miles down the road, I have always had an affinity for Beeston; it just always seemed to have more personality and community spirit than the part of Wollaton in which I grew up. I have lived in Beeston for eight years now, and although interested in politics would not describe myself as an activist or an advocate of direct action; more someone who occasionally expresses concern for the world in which I live.

I am probably preaching to the converted here, but Nick Palmer was always a delight on the occasions on which I have sought his counsel; prompt to respond, willing to explain his reasons if he disagreed, and also willing to admit when he made mistakes. Of course, he is a politician, so I don’t kid myself that he is entirely altruistic – I suspect that his Hustings confession that it was a mistake to support the war in Iraq was at least partly politically motivated.

Anna Soubry is a very different animal, and that in itself is not a bad thing, until you consider some constituents’ experiences:

  • Slow to respond to correspondence, and in many cases, not responding at all
  • Very eager to speak up for the needs of the constituency, even though many of the residents of Broxtowe won’t even recognise the concerns
  • Misrepresenting* issues, such as her comment in Parliament about the postal workers (as reported by Matt at the time)

Now, in her role as Public Health Minister, she has stoked quite a fire, which has been well-reported and much-debated elsewhere (including this wry piece of satire), and her appearance on last week’s Question Time was actually quite intriguing; who would have thought the Member of Parliament for Broxtowe would get jeered by an audience in Weymouth? If you are anti-Soubry, you would not have needed to deconstruct her performance as she did herself few favours.

Of course, it would seem as though Anna Soubry is being prepared for great things by the Conservative Party; her rapid elevation to Junior Minister suggests that. However, what use is that when she is in real danger of losing her seat at the next election? The cynic would suggest that any publicity is good publicity, at least in the eyes of the party mandarins.

I asked my fellow Broxtowe-dwelling colleagues what they thought of her (admittedly a self-selecting sample, if you consider where I work). A Kimberley dweller said that she was doorstepped for over twenty minutes by Anna Soubry while canvassing for the 2010 Election, and Anna just would not take no for an answer. My colleague hasn’t seen her in Kimberley since then.

“So what?” I hear you cry, “that is just what politicians are like in this day and age. That is why turnout is falling; we don’t really have much of a choice.”

This, dear reader, is why I am going to finish where I started; Broxtowe is a microcosm of the country. A wafer-thin margin keeps the ruling elite clinging on. The difference is that Nick Palmer and Anna Soubry are very different creatures, and now we can judge each of them on their track records as the Member of Parliament for Broxtowe. As constituents, we do have a real choice to make, and your vote at the next election will make a real difference.




* I use the word “misrepresenting” advisedly

6 thoughts on “Soubs Salute/ The Back of Beck? / Guest Post by Rish Baruah.

  1. the observer says:

    Although Soubry dropped a few clangers at the start she’s getting good now. Nick’s going to need every bit of support he can muster to win this one

    • beestonia says:

      I’d say that her clangers are increasing now the media have a stronger spotlight on her. I really can’t see much chance of her holding the seat, unless the polls improve by around 15% minimum in 24 months. That is extremely unlikely. The other factor that aided her win in 2010 was the strength of the Lib Dem vote moving from Lab-Lib (very little seems to have gone Con-Lib). As the LD vote has collapsed, she cannot rely on that either. As for Ashcroft money, that gave her campaign a spending power well above Palmers…not there. I’d be willing to stick a straight £50 on it now, if you’re confident?

  2. Judy S says:

    Getting good at what exactly? Getting herself on TV? Getting herself in the papers? She is certainly not good at answering questions she does not like, or emails! But we must not get complacent that Nick will just walk back into his seat, he still needs the votes.

  3. I am completely shocked at the possible demise of Beck’s. I went in Saturday morning & everything seemed fine. Purchased some cat food, chocolate and some neat biscuits with teddy bears on the top. Served with a smile and a ‘thanks babe’ from one of the cheery female assistants. Somehow I thought they were the owners, not employees. Just hope the news isn’t true. And with no chocolate shop now either. Where is a lad to go for these cheap goodies?

  4. Peter Bone says:

    Interesting comments about our MP, which I entirely endorse. I should point out that it is by no means a foregone conclusion that Nick Palmer will be the Labour candidate for Broxtowe in 2015. The selection hasn’t yet taken place.

  5. Chris says:

    Gosh this mirrors me and my thoughts to a tee. Wollaton dweller to Beeston. Enthused into politics by Nick’s approach, with the legs now taken from under me by Anna’s take on the same role.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s